How To Determine Your Lawsuit Target Value

Are You Worth Suing? How to Figure Out Your Lawsuit Target Value.

Knowing all your risks and exactly what you have exposed is also part of good asset protection planning.

Consider the following when determining your own defensive needs and exactly what you have to lose if you don't act BEFORE a problem arises, when your options are the most cost effective and predictable.  

Are your real estate assets exposed? 

Personal residences. 

For many successful Arizona residents, home equity is an asset that represents a significant portion of their net worth because they have been disciplined in paying down their mortgage and/or the high price of the home itself. Creditor protection on your primary residence varies from state to state (from a few thousand dollars to unlimited dollar value) and is generally referred to as the “homestead” exemption. This is protection is available on a single primary residence only, so if you have multiple personal residences or vacation homes, those aren't protected.  This includes those properties titled in the name of your “revocable living trust” or family trust, which are not effective asset protection vehicles for you, during your life.  

To determine your home's exposed equity, simply take the current market value and subtract any mortgage or other debt and your state's homestead exemption. This exemption amount is typically found in a list of state bankruptcy statutes that also lists your other creditor exempt assets and the limited protection that the law may provide to non-exempt assets. As an example, a physician I just spoke with in Scottsdale has a $985K value home with only $50K left on the mortgage and the Arizona homestead exemption is $250K*. This means he has $685K exposed in his home, or about a third of his current net worth. That's an amount worth collecting against for almost any creditor, and the idea that judgment creditors can't or won't take your home is a common anecdotal myth that makes collections attorneys laugh. 

Investment real estate. 

Any investment real estate you hold personally or in any revocable estate planning entity is exposed to all your personal and professional liability, as is any income stream it produces. If it is properly owned by an LLC and you are personally member of that LLC, any income stream it distributes to you is generally also exposed. Simple math on your exposure: sale value - debt = exposed equity (plus any cashflow it produces). 

Liquid assets (non-exempt)

Your personal hard-dollar exposure here is the sum total of the following personal property assets that are titled in your own name, the name of your medical practice, or in the name of any revocable estate planning trust, etc.

• Cash, stocks, bonds, CDs, money market accounts, precious metals, and other liquid cash equivalents;
• Investment grade personal property like jewelry, coins, art, antiques, sports memorabilia, high value firearm collections, etc.;
• Income from other sources, including current or expected inheritance distributions, royalties, payments on any notes your hold;
• Intellectual property and any associated income;
• Other business income; 
• Your garnishable, personally-earned income; and 
• High value “toys” like boats, aircraft, exotic cars, etc. 

Exempt assets (or are they?) 

Qualified retirement plan assets are generally well protected across the United States, but the limits of that protection, like homestead, also vary from state to state. Refer to a resource like the one provided above on homestead to determine your local limits and conditions. There are differences in both dollar amount of the protection, which assets are exempt, and even the residency conditions required to avail of a specific state's law for recent transplants. For example, a state could require you to have lived in that state for 24 months contiguously for their creditor protection laws to apply and may say that if you haven't, the laws of the last state you were a resident of will apply. 

Pay attention to details when making these calculations. Many assets are only, “Exempt if…”, meaning specific conditions need to be met. Examples of such assets include the cash value of life insurance, which might be protected if personally owned or in a life insurance trust (but which may require a lengthy vesting period and may have low dollar limits) or may be exposed if your business or medical practice is the policy owner. 

Don't forget your intangible assets 

Not all assets can be insured or appraised, so factor in goodwill, reputation, seniority, and the other subjective factors that contribute to your income and success. Loss or damage of any of these assets may be a serious, permanent threat to your income. 

*Prop 409 raised Arizona homestead to $450K in late 2022. The timing of this change, who is included and other related legal issues are still being disputed in Arizona courts. Until this issue is resolved, we (and many other Arizona lawyers) are erring on the side of caution and using the previous limit of $250K in our exempt asset calculations.

Nothing in a general public blog format like this is legal advice, nor can it replace the guidance of an attorney.